Y
Yesterday, my old friend Diana Yin-Chang Inch posted a NAN/NAAM on Facebook asking BEST/WORST Adoption movies & WHY There’s some nice discussion, and I linked my own list of favorite adoption films but not with the whys because that would be a lot of work. Besides, I’m suffering from a sleep disorder and can either not sleep or can’t wake up, which is ruining posting every day. I’m awake now and trying to catch up.
Inspired by Diana, I decided to recycle my review of what is probably my favorite adoption movie, That Hagan Girl. with a few additional comments here. The review, Adoption Fims: That Hagan Girl. Adoption and Betrayal in an Otherwise Bad Fim or You Think You’ve Got Problems, Be Glad You’re Not Mary Hagan is posted on Academia.com, which you can read for free.
As you can tell by the title of my review, That Hagan Girl is not a great adoption film like Secrets and Lies. The film was supposed to be Shirley Temple’s breakout adult film, and it was a flop. She hated it and so did her co-start Ronald Reagan, who wanted it buried. So did the critics. It was named one of the Worst 50 films of all time.. That was in 1978 before the advent of Lifetime Movies, and its plethora of adoption-related films, hit our screens. For crazy birthmom films see The Psycho Party Planner
Outside of Turner Classics, which showed That Hagan GIrl at odd hours when nobody is up, the film was not easily available when I watched it the first time. A friend sent me a bootleg CD. I was prepared to moan and groan and laugh at it, but viewing it through the adoptee lens, I ended up crying in places, despite the very weird ending, that to this day dumfounds everybody including the stars.
From my review:
I have never seen any film that addresses adoption lies, bastard anger, isolation, and identity dislocation as That Hagan Girldoes–even if it doesn’t mean to. In its clumsy way, the film speaks to Class Bastard—adoptees—at a gut level. I am pretty sure that it would set off the hair-trigger many adoptees itch their fingers on!
Maybe I’m crazy, but I think That Hagan Girl is a hidden gem.
BTW Secrets and Lies was nominated for several Academy Awards, and Bastard Nation attend Oscar Night and got on TV.
____________
Poke the Bear 2026
NABLOPOMO 2026
Day 14– 16 days to go!

